Me, pissing all over the World Cup
[The following is largely copied from comments I made on a post on World Cup at Pandagon , which were met with protest and dismay.]
I played soccer as a kid, so I actually do know what offsides is, but in general, it’s like any other sport. While I can appreciate the physical grace and hard work of the participants, I don’t care much about it. Plus, I have soccer to thank for my two-different-sizes feet (I got to the ball first, the opposing player kicked my foot instead, like, REALLY HARD).
I don’t think liking it is a sign of anything really special *or* horrible about a person.
But I would disagree with those who claim that following World Cup makes you part of the “world community.” It makes you part of the sports-watching world community, which is largely male and definitely male-centric. Comparing it favorably to American Football seems, to me, a bit of a dick size war, like it really matters which sport is “best”. And the game as industry has the same problems any other large, male-centric sport does:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2010/jun/09/world-cup-2010-women-ads
Much like the Super Bowl, UK World Cup advertising focuses on men even though many watchers in the UK will be women.
http://fromaleftwing.blogspot.com/2010/05/for-nike-women-seem-to-be-good-just-for.html
Nike 2010 WC ad typical in its sexism.
http://www.undomesticgoddess.com/2010/04/world-cup-runneth-over-with-sexism.html
South Africa has poor controls over sex trafficking and rape. This
means that loads of visitors to SA will be using women for sex who
aren’t sex workers by choice, and women who go to the games have to be
very careful not to go anywhere alone.
http://www.rnw.nl/english/article/anti-rape-condom-ready-sa-world-cup
http://www.thefirstpost.co.uk/62758,news-comment,news-politics,world-cup-fans-to-get-30000-rape-axe-barbed-condoms
A doctor has developed an anti-rape condom which she wants to
distribute in SA during the World Cup. Doesn’t look like it’s
available, though.
http://blog.taragana.com/sports/2010/06/09/uk-police-warn-of-world-cup-domestic-violence-109570/
The usual, unsubstantiated story of “domestic violence follows
favored team’s loss” which gets trotted out every Super Bowl?
According to this story, “[England’s] Home Office says that during the
last World Cup, on England match days, the number of domestic violence
cases rose by around 25 percent, and when England was eliminated from
the competition, that figure rose to more than 30 percent.” I will try
to find more information on this.
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/news/2918868/Bid-to-ban-England-tops-in-World-Cup-pubs.html
“Killjoy cops have urged landlords to bar anyone wearing a Three
Lions top. They want to avoid a repeat of violence which has marred
previous events, particularly if England lose.”
http://www.amnestyusa.org/document.php?id=ENGNAU2010061117037&lang=e
“There has been an increase in police harassment of informal
traders (hawkers), homeless South Africans, and refugees and migrants
who are living in shelters or high density inner city accommodation.
This harassment has included police raids, arbitrary arrests,
ill-treatment and extortion, as well as destruction of informal
housing. The tearing down of informal housing has taken place without
prior notice, provision of adequate alternative housing or compensation
and in violation of domestic law prohibiting forced evictions.”
You might think this is just me complaining about something I don't care about anyway, and that it's all multicultural and shit and why am I pissing all over it? Surely I'm just being America-centric?
Well. Women in non-US cultures aren’t uniformly “wooah World Cup”. Plenty of them find it an exercise in male privilege and glorification:
http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/laurie-penny/2010/06/world-cup-football-england
Liberal alarm bells can’t help but start ringing when a bunch of overpaid PE teachers get together to orchestrate a month of corporate-sponsored quasi-xenophobia; however, as soon as World Cup fever rolls around, members of the otherwise uninterested bourgeois left feel obliged to muster at least a sniffle of enthusiasm, sensing that not to do so is somehow elitist.
This is a misplaced notion: football is no longer the people’s sport. Just look at the brutal contempt that the police reserve for fans, or count the number of working-class Britons who can afford to attend home matches, much less the festivities in South Africa. Then there’s the uncomfortable fact that the World Cup is only and always about men.
http://florycalavera.blogspot.com/2010/06/of-soccer-and-sexism.html
There’s one thing I’m not thrilled about, however: the fact that the World Cup craze, in addition to fueling enthusiasm for soccer, has also intensified the Chilean media’s already pervasive objectification of women.
http://bradmillershero.blogspot.com/2010/06/bebe-world-cup-ad.html
[World Cup. What are the men doing? They are the stars, playing the game, receiving the accolades, partying, murdering important political figures’ great granddaughters, etc. And the women? Oh, they get to play football, too- well, play play football. In stupid dresses. While wearing high heels. And a metric fuck ton of makeup.



Thank you. Could not have said it better myself.
Reply to this
Thank you, From A Left Wing! Your blog post was galvanizing.
Reply to this
So you want to debunk the stereotype that women watch and care about football too(and NO am not gonna call it soccer), by "pissing all over the world cup"?.
I thought you were gonna complain about the Malian referee, silly me.
Does not compute logic. You are just basically reaffirming the stereotype, women hardly care about sports at all, unless is for political reasons.
Of course claiming WC2010 basically just a dick size contest, and just causing from just about anything from sexism, violence, DUI murder, racism to fascism. Makes me think you maybe dont like the world cup? Am gonna put it up with maybe...
Reply to this
osborn18, I don't really care one way or the other about it. Perhaps you should read more carefully -- I said that the comparison of US football with World Cup football seemed like kind of a dick size contest.
Noting the sexism in something you don't love doesn't mean you hate it. There's sexism in things I like, also. Fiction. Science. TV. Movies.
I also didn't claim I want to debunk any stereotype about women not liking football. Many of them obviously do. There are reasons some don't, and those who are borderline might lose interest based on the sexism.
Reply to this